top of page
Titles.png

Everyday Comforts

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Tomorrow 3:00 PM - 4:00 PM
Pickup Address: 605 East Broad Street unit 7, Mansfield, TX 76063-1766

Menu

Cookie Packages

Our 3 Pack is the answer for small celebrations, sweet gifts, or anyone wanting a taste without deciding on just one favorite. With this set, you simply pick any three cookies - like our bestselling brown butter varieties, featured monthly flavors, or a playful Cookie Monster - to mix, match, and create your own little box of joy. Each 3 Pack is made fresh in Mansfield, TX, so you know you're gifting (or enjoying) gourmet cookies made with intention. The 3 Pack is perfect as a thoughtful thank-you, a teacher surprise, or a just-because treat. Searching for small cookie gift sets nearby or wanting to try a variety? Our individual cookie pack options make it easy to send comfort when it's needed most - from Mansfield to anywhere in Texas. It's especially handy for online shoppers interested in buy 3-pack cookie assortments or creating quick, meaningful surprises. At Comeback Cookie, great things really do come in threes.

$13.00

Popular

The Comeback Cookie 4 Pack is the perfect way to enjoy a little variety with an extra touch of sweetness. With this set, you get to choose any four cookies - mix and match your favorite gourmet flavors, bestselling brown butter varieties, monthly specials, or colorful classics - and pair them with your choice of creamy Biscoff Banana Pudding or our classic OG Banana Pudding. Each 4 Pack is freshly made in Mansfield, TX, giving you a delicious combination of handmade cookies and comforting homemade-style pudding. It’s perfect for a small celebration, a thoughtful gift, a weekend treat, or simply when four cookies and a little extra sweetness are exactly what you need. For anyone looking to buy gourmet cookies online in Texas or create a personalized dessert box, the 4 Pack makes it easy to choose your favorites and make every bite your own. At Comeback Cookie, four cookies and a delicious pudding are all you need to make an ordinary moment feel a little more special.

$26.00

The Comeback Cookie 6 Pack is the sweet spot for sharing or stocking up on family favorites. In this pack, you get the freedom to select six cookies - choose a single gourmet flavor or mix from beloved classics and monthly specials until your box is filled with all the right tastes. Every 6 Pack is freshly baked in Mansfield, TX, making it well-suited for hosting a gathering, planning ahead for celebrations, or simply enjoying cookies throughout the week. This large gourmet cookie pack is ideal for gifting friends, bringing to work gatherings, or adding to dessert displays at your next party. For those searching for gourmet cookie gift sets in Texas, or wanting to bulk order cookies for events, the 6 Pack offers an easy route to more variety and abundance.  Buying cookies online is made simple with flexible pack sizes, ensuring nobody has to miss out on their favorite. A 6 Pack from Comeback Cookie means you're sharing more than dessert - you're passing along a moment of comfort and care.

$26.00

Popular

Sometimes, the moment calls for generosity that only a dozen fresh cookies can offer. Our Dozen pack delivers twelve handmade cookies - ready for sharing at family nights, office gatherings, or as a generous gift to show someone you're thinking of them. Choose to fill your dozen with any mix of our award-winning brown butter recipes, monthly feature flavors, or colorful classics, all baked with heart in Mansfield, TX. This large cookie box makes it easy to buy a dozen cookies online in Texas and bring joy to every corner of your life. These fresh gourmet cookies are ideal for holiday gifting, neighborhood celebrations, or simply stocking up to savor over time. If you're planning ahead for a party or looking for a classic cookie gift, our dozen brings bakery-quality warmth home. Each order is carefully arranged so every cookie is ready to celebrate life's big and small comebacks. The Dozen brings a sense of abundance - and a taste of connection - to every occasion.

$51.00

Specialty Desserts

Comeback Cookie's Biscoff Banana Puddin' blends the buttery smoothness of Biscoff spread with layers of velvety banana pudding and crunchy cookie crumbles to create a dessert that feels both nostalgic and brand new. This Southern classic, reimagined in Mansfield, TX, is hand-layered to give you every dimension - a taste of tradition sweetened with a little modern joy. Each spoonful pairs spiced Biscoff notes with soft banana flavor, finished with just the right amount of crunch from cookie pieces. The decadent result is comforting for anyone who loves the richness of banana desserts or wants to enjoy the combination of creamy and crisp. Searching for a banana pudding with Biscoff spread, or something a little different for your next family meal? You can enjoy it solo, bring it to gatherings, or add it to your cookie order for a little extra celebration. This layered banana pudding is perfect for sharing and turns everyday moments into reasons to savor. The Biscoff Banana Puddin' is a specialty you won't want to keep to yourself.

$10.00

Popular

The Cheesecake from Comeback Cookie brings classic comfort straight to your kitchen with every forkful. Made in Mansfield, TX, this rich, creamy cheesecake is lovingly baked on a buttery graham cracker crust, promising a melt-in-your-mouth experience from the first bite to the last. Our focus on careful preparation and high-quality ingredients is what makes this dessert stand out among bakery treats. (Seasonal flavors vary) Each cheesecake is thoughtfully baked small-batch style, ensuring the perfect creamy texture you expect with notes of real vanilla and tang. The golden graham crust provides a hint of crunch and warmth, giving you a homemade flavor you can feel good sharing at birthdays, celebrations, or simply to turn an everyday gathering into a heartfelt memory. Ideal for gifting or brightening someone's week, these cheesecakes are best enjoyed with the people close to you. Our reputation in Mansfield for carefully made cheesecake gives peace of mind, whether you serve it at home or send a box along as a sweet gesture.

$12.00

Layers of cookies, creamy pudding, more cookies, more pudding, and a fresh whipped topping. Classic, comforting, and made with your choice of fresh bananas or no bananas.

$10.00

Serves 10–14 people. Whole cheesecakes require a minimum of 48 hours’ advance notice.

$80.00

Our Packages

Explore Our Flavors

Discover our delicious range of freshly baked cookies below.

​

Please note: Our cookies are sold exclusively in our assorted packs. Head over to Our Packages section to build your perfect box!

Spooky S’mores

✓ Ways to Enjoy Your Cookie Microwave: Warm your cookie for 10–20 seconds for that fresh-from-the-oven taste. Air Fryer: Warm for 5–10 seconds. Freezing: Store your cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe Ziploc bag or sealed container to maintain freshness. Ready to Enjoy? Allow frozen cookies to thaw at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or microwave for 15–20 seconds. ✓ Allergen Information Our cookies are prepared in a kitchen that handles wheat (gluten), dairy, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Comeback Cookie Disclosure: We are not a gluten-free or dairy-free bakery. Ingredients and allergens may vary by cookie flavor.

Chocolate Chip Cookie.png

Frankenstein Monster

✓ Ways to Enjoy Your Cookie Microwave: Warm your cookie for 10–20 seconds for that fresh-from-the-oven taste. Air Fryer: Warm for 5–10 seconds. Freezing: Store your cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe Ziploc bag or sealed container to maintain freshness. Ready to Enjoy? Allow frozen cookies to thaw at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or microwave for 15–20 seconds. ✓ Allergen Information Our cookies are prepared in a kitchen that handles wheat (gluten), dairy, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Comeback Cookie Disclosure: We are not a gluten-free or dairy-free bakery. Ingredients and allergens may vary by cookie flavor.

Chocolate Chip Cookie.png

Black Velvet Cookies & Cream

✓ Ways to Enjoy Your Cookie Microwave: Warm your cookie for 10–20 seconds for that fresh-from-the-oven taste. Air Fryer: Warm for 5–10 seconds. Freezing: Store your cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe Ziploc bag or sealed container to maintain freshness. Ready to Enjoy? Allow frozen cookies to thaw at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or microwave for 15–20 seconds. ✓ Allergen Information Our cookies are prepared in a kitchen that handles wheat (gluten), dairy, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Comeback Cookie Disclosure: We are not a gluten-free or dairy-free bakery. Ingredients and allergens may vary by cookie flavor.

Chocolate Chip Cookie.png

Apple Snickerdoodle

✓ Ways to Enjoy Your Cookie Microwave: Warm your cookie for 10–20 seconds for that fresh-from-the-oven taste. Air Fryer: Warm for 5–10 seconds. Freezing: Store your cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe Ziploc bag or sealed container to maintain freshness. Ready to Enjoy? Allow frozen cookies to thaw at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, or microwave for 15–20 seconds. ✓ Allergen Information Our cookies are prepared in a kitchen that handles wheat (gluten), dairy, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Comeback Cookie Disclosure: We are not a gluten-free or dairy-free bakery. Ingredients and allergens may vary by cookie flavor.

Chocolate Chip Cookie.png
​

Return Policy

Due to the perishable nature of our cookies, we do not accept returns or exchanges. If you are not satisfied with your purchase, please contact us at hello@comebackcookie.com within 24 hours of delivery with a photo and description of the issue. We will make every effort to ensure your satisfaction. Claims sent after 24 hours are not eligible for a reship or refund.

 

Service Areas: Proudly baking and delivering fresh treats across Mansfield, Arlington, Grand Prairie, and the surrounding DFW areas.

bottom of page